Showing posts with label Transformer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Transformer. Show all posts

23 Jul 2011

Transformers 3 – The fall of Optimus Prime

Transformers 3 – The fall of Optimus PrimeEveryone who knows about films, will know about Transformers. There is a lot wrong with the franchise even though it is commercially very successful, but then again the disgraced and disgusting News of the World was incredibly commercially successful as well. Media commercial success is not a guide to the integrity of a film, book or publication.

I, of course understand that expecting a Michael Bay film to deliver some food for thought on the ethics of war, the development of the characters or a storyline which actually makes sense is expecting too much and is unfair. People watch these films for the adrenaline rush – that’s fine, everyone enjoys a little bit of escapism.

But in his quest for dollars and box office records, Bay has single-handedly destroyed the character of the main hero of the film – Optimus Prime. The Prime I remember from reading the old comics and watching the old cartoons was a great leader who could always make the right decision no matter what the circumstances. But in the new film, Prime executes his former mentor Sentinel whilst begging for mercy and proclaims he will, ‘kill them [the Decepticon] all’. It was not that Prime actually did these things that made me disillusioned it was the fact that Bay portrayed Prime as being comfortable and at ease with his deeds. There was no self doubt, no apprehension or moral quandary within Optimus Prime.

Hollywood films have long portrayed sadistic violence, victor’s justice and frequently morphed justice into violence giving rise to a distinctly harsh American attitude towards justice. This frequently comes up – the last time such a clash between these different conceptions of justice occurred was in the case of the Lockerbie bomber, who was allowed to return to Libya on the grounds of his poor deteriorating health. The American side was furious demanding retribution, but the Europeans were shocked at what they seemed to perceive as the American thirst for revenge. There was a distinct culture clash within ‘the West’ – that alone should prove that there is no ‘one’ West.

But Optimus Prime has been militarised American style – the impression given is that Prime would acknowledge and accept torture as well to achieve his goals, under the new look franchise of the Transformers. Prime is seen taking sides in human conflicts, leading the Autobots to bomb an Iranian nuclear site that is deemed ‘illegal’. Such blatant propaganda only detracts from the value of the film – American audiences will lap this up no doubt. Already conservative groups in America applaud the Transformers as being ‘patriotic’.
Apart from ‘freedom’, Prime speaks about little else. The compassion and mercy that is supposed to be part of his character is lost somewhere when he rips throats, hearts and beheads other robots. Bay destroyed the one thing about Prime’s Autobots – they were above human conflict and Prime himself was above the culture of revenge and tribal justice that ravaged their homeland Cybertron.
There, of course exists even throughout the old comics, a tension between the saintly aspirations of Optimus and the violent practicalities of being a leader. But Bay never explores that – he uses the robots in the film as playthings rather than developing them as real characters. That was what was most disappointing about the whole experience.

The audience never gets to understand Optimus – he is just the chief executor, a brilliant gladiator and of course a “freedom fighter”’. Perhaps that is the one redeeming feature of the whole film – Optimus’s creed of ‘freedom is the right of every sentient being’ stays throughout the whole franchise.

But Bay’s representation of the characters is woeful. The ploy of getting Shia LeBeouf a good looking co-star has meant the great tradition of objectifying women as a prize or reward for the hero’s conquest continues. If I wanted to see a cheap juvenile film, I would have just seen a Salman Khan film.

What’s more, the whole dynamic between Sentinel and Optimus is never explored throughout the film. Neither is the audience clued in about how Megatron featured in the relationship. Sentinel was the ‘Hero’ who had fallen and succumbed to violence but again this tension is never explored and Optimus’s reaction is never fully developed. Too much emphasis is given on the vacuous and empty-headed characters of Sam Witwhicky and his new girl-friend Carly.

It isn’t too much to ask for a bit of development on the characters – to portray a sense of empathy, to give an insight into the conflicts that plague the Transformers and their leaders beyond epic gladiatorial duels.

It is possible to combine a deep story with action and commercial success. The new Batman franchise has achieved that magnificently. The real coup, director Christopher Nolan pulled off was developing Batman’s character whilst providing him with equally complex villains such as the Joker. The tension and dynamic of this relationship defines the film’s conflict and its main premise.

Transformers 3 seems to suggest anything is permissible in the cause of freedom. Freedom is the new ‘Crusaders religion’, fight in the name of freedom and you don’t have to care about conscience, ethics or morality.

It’s just a shame that the good name of Optimus Prime had to be sacrificed at the altar of American patriotism. Not to forget here the rightful and just critique of the Pakistani culture which has its own problems with justice and attitudes to violence and war.
Optimus Prime was supposed to be the reluctant warrior, who always stressed peace whenever possible and who had a great distaste for violence. I am not suggesting pacifism as a creed worth holding – we do live in the real world but some sort of framework of ethics that guides us through the messy business of conflict is necessary.
Heroes are supposed to represent a side of human nature that we all aspire to, a paragon for a great ideal who have a central animating moral vision.

11 Jul 2011

Transformers 3: Great effects, greater flaws


Bay made a good movie in the first Transformers and then proceeded to make two bad sequels.
Watching a Michael Bay movie must be similar to what I imagine it is like for patients on the receiving end of a colonoscopy – there is always a bit of a fear. After all, this is the director who, in 2001, took a historic tragedy and unintentionally turned it into a three-hour comedy in the form of Pearl Harbor.
The experience is numbing, considering that you can fit the plots of Bay’s entire work on the back of a matchbook; after either ordeal is over, any enjoyment you may have felt is accompanied by feelings of guilt.
Dark of the Moon is the third installment in the Transformers movie franchise, and like its predecessors, it has again been directed by Michael Bay. Bay, who shocked everyone in 2007 by making a good movie in the first Transformers (70 per cent fresh rating amongst Rotten Tomatoes’ “Top Critics”) film, decided that one good movie was enough, and proceeded to make an awful sequel in Revenge of the Fallen, which lacked what little plot development and subtlety the first had (who can forget the awfully gratuitous shots of Megan Fox’s hypnotizing rear?).
Thankfully, In Dark of the Moon, there is a more of a plot than Revenge of the Fallen. We learn that the space race in the 60s was motivated by alien technology discovered on the moon. The movie tells us that the technology allows transportation across galaxies of objects of huge masses, including planets. In Dark of the Moon, the evil Decepticons attempt to use the technology to teleport their war torn planet Cybertron next to Earth, so that they can use human slaves to rebuild it. One wonders if the writers considered that a planet ten times the size of Earth, would have too huge a gravitational pull to be able to sit in orbit?
To keep everyone interested, there are human characters as well. Sam Witwicky (Shia LaBeouf) is back, and struggling to find a job, despite having saved humanity twice. Nonsensically, the movie has us believe that he can’t find work, but the writers are less concerned with logic, and more with the average male audience member identifying with the movie’s lead.
He has a hot new girl in Carly (Rosie Huntington-Whiteley), who plays the clichéd girlfriend in distress role. Other familiar faces also return, though the actors seem tired in their roles. New characters include Sam’s new boss Bruce Brazos, given an eccentric edge by the brilliant John Malkovich. Others include government official Mearing (Frances McDormand), and Carly’s billionaire boss (Patrick Dempsey).
These human characters are given more screen time than the transformers, because Michael Bay’s only interest in the robots is playing with them on screen. Aside from transformers Optimus Prime (Peter Cullen), and Sentinel Prime (Leonard Nimoy), Michael Bay shows absolutely no interest in developing the characters of movie’s CGI stars. Even the character, Bumblebee, who was essentially the star of the first film, has little tangible presence here.
But, the largest example of Michael Bay’s indifference to the bots is when a certain main Autobot character is killed off nonchalantly during the first half of the film, with absolutely no acknowledgement or regret expressed by any of the Autobots, despite having had significant presence in the first two films. It leaves the audience wondering why they should care about the movie’s characters, when the director himself clearly does not.
Dark of the Moon also suffers from some poor editing. At times the narrative lacks coherence, with scenes jumping from one plot point to the next, with little transition, other than bits of dull and obligatory pieces of exposition, explaining the scenes to follow.
What Bay is good at is explosive action. The last sixty minutes of Dark of the Moon are essentially the last fifteen minutes of the first film on steroids, and quite entertaining. Some of the one-on-one combat sequences are especially enjoyable, and the action set pieces overall are simply awesome. The CGI is also phenomenal, with all the transformers looking and moving realistically.
The movie was designed with 3D in mind from the ground up, which I enjoyed at the Cineplex at Clifton, Karachi. While I personally dislike the effect in most films, I have to admit that it was especially well done in Dark of the Moon, and certainly the best I’ve experienced since Avatar.
In the end though, Dark of the Moon is like going on a date with that hot girlfriend who bores you to death; you feel you can’t quite blame yourself for agreeing to a third date and putting up with her nonsense, even though you probably should have known better.
The movie has a run time of 155 minutes, and is rated PG-13.

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.